Midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating but are always. Dec 09, 2010 dawkins selfish gene is now approaching its 35th anniversary. The phrase selfish gene in the title of the book was coined by dawkins as a provocative way of expressing the genecentric view of evolution, which holds that evolution is best viewed as acting on genes, and that selection at the level of. In 1979 she issued a scathing critique of richard dawkins popular book the selfish gene, taking issue with what she called his crude, cheap, blurred genetics. Mary midgley september, 1919 october 10, 2018 issue. She was a senior lecturer in philosophy at the university of newcastle upon tyne, and is best known for her popular works on religion, science and ethics. Mary midgley, 99, moral philosopher for the general reader. At one point in the early 1980s, midgley explained her previous disinclination to engage with dawkinss 1976 book the selfish gene by pronouncing it superfluous to break a butterfly upon a. Mary midgley psychology wiki fandom powered by wikia.
I didnt read the selfish gene when it came out, but when i did read it. Midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating but are always unrealistic. Mary midgley, the myths we live by 2004 midgleys first book, beast and man published in 1978, was an examination of human nature and a reaction against both the perceived reductionism of sociobiology, and the relativism and behaviorism she saw as prevalent in much of social science. Mary midgley, moral philosopher who took on richard. Time for a midlife crisis at least that is the conclusion midgley draws in the solitary self. Her latest book is provocatively titled are you an. There is a kind of gestaltshift between the two positions which makes it hard to change, and hard to raise questions on the matter at all without becoming embattled. Darwin and the selfish gene, which was published in 2010. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the solitary self. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. At somerville, she became friends with iris murdoch, elizabeth anscombe and philippa foot. Thomas hobbes invented, in leviathan, the modern idea of the individual. Midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating but. Unlike dawkins title, which sets out the programme he pursues, midgleys title describes the view she is combating.
Mary midgley, who has died aged 99, was a moral philosopher who made enormous contributions to human thinking on questions such as the self. Oct 10, 2018 mary midgley september, 1919 october 10, 2018 carol nicholson on a remarkable ethicist and philosophy now contributor. Why richard dawkins went further than hobbes and ended up ludicrously wrong. She studied at the university of cambridge during the second world war alongside mary warnock and the writer iris murdoch. She was a senior lecturer in philosophy at newcastle university and is known for her work on science, ethics and animal rights. Mary midgley, one of the leading and most illuminating moral philosophers of our time, published her last book what is philosophy for. This should not need mentioning, but richard dawkinss book the selfish gene has succeeded in confusing a number of people about. What mackie welcomes in dawkins is a new, biologicallooking kind of support for philosophic egoism. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Exchanging views in philosophy with a twoyear timelag is gettin like conversation with the andromeda.
This essay was developed from her latest book the solitary self acumen. Among moral philosophers mary midgley has a razorsharp mind, and when she speaks i listen. Book description renowned philosopher mary midgley explores the nature of our moral constitution to challenge the view that reduces human motivation to selfinterest. She was educated at downe house school in cold ash and read classics mods and greats at somerville college, oxford, gaining a first. Midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives. Genes cannot be selfish or unselfish, any more than atoms can be jealous, elephants abstract or biscuits teleological. Dawkins uses the term selfish gene as a way of expressing the genecentred view of evolution as opposed to the views focused on the organism and. The meaning of gaia 2007 imprint academic isbn 1845400801 edited volume the solitary self.
Mary midgley, moral philosopher who took on richard dawkins. As the title suggests, in the book she takes up her longstanding disagreement with richard dawkins and his the selfish gene, an extremely important book which nonetheless appeals to a rather limited understanding of darwin, according to midgley. The essential mary midgley 2005 routledge isbn 0415346428 ed david midgley with foreword by james lovelock. The essential mary midgley collects for the first time the very best of this famous philosophers work, described by the financial times as common sense philosophy of the. Selfish genes and social darwinism at the wayback machine archived 31 october 2005, philosophy, vol 58, 1983, pp. Desmond morriss the naked ape was a bestseller and of course richard dawkins published the selfish gene in 1976. Darwin and the selfish gene, she argues that simple onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating but are always unrealistic. This should not need mentioning, but richard dawkinss book the selfish gene has succeeded in confusing a number of people about it, including mr j. She strongly opposes reductionist and scientistic philosophies and is especially concerned with attempts, as she sees it, to make science function as a. Mary midgley is one of the most respected moral philosophers of her generation and the author of many books, including beast and man, wickedness and the. Darwin and the selfish gene, she argues that simple onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be.
Darwin and the selfish gene 1 by midgley, mary isbn. Mary midgley, philosopher, 1919 to 2018 financial times. Apr 04, 2014 at one point in the early 1980s, midgley explained her previous disinclination to engage with dawkinss 1976 book the selfish gene by pronouncing it superfluous to break a butterfly upon a. The solitary self darwin and the selfish gene taylor. This manifesto, prominently placed at the beginning and end of dawkinss book. The selfish gene is a 1976 book on evolution by the biologist richard dawkins, in which the author builds upon the principal theory of george c. Mary midgley is one of the most respected moral philosophers of her generation and the author of many books, including beast and man, wickedness and the myths we live by.
Part of mary midgleys concern is that richard dawkins account of the selfish gene serves as a moral and ideological justification for selfishness to be adopted by modern human societies as simply following nature, providing an excuse for behavior with bad consequences for future human society. Mary midgley, nee scrutton, was born in london in 1919. I wrote no books until i was a good 50, she has said, and im jolly glad because i didnt know what i thought before then. The moral philosopher mary midgley has never enjoyed the popular renown. Oct 12, 2018 in 1979, following the publication of dawkinss the selfish gene, mary midgley wrote a highly personal attack in the journal philosophy in which she accused the scientist of an extreme. Unlike dawkins title, which sets out the programme he pursues, midgleys title describes the view she is. Mary midgley, who has died aged 99, was an important writer on ethics, the relations of humans and animals, our tendency to misconstrue science, and the role of myth and poetry. Renowned philosopher mary midgley explores the nature of our moral constitution to challenge the view that reduces human motivation to selfinterest. Aug 10, 2014 midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating but are always unrealistic. Everyone was telling him he was the cats whiskers, you see, and i wasnt. A senior lecturer in philosophy at newcastle university, she was known for her work on science, ethics and animal rights.
In 1979, following the publication of dawkinss the selfish gene, mary midgley wrote a highly personal attack in the journal philosophy in which she accused the scientist of an extreme. Midgleys argument in her new book is against a form of scientific. Her memoir, the owl of minerva, was published by routledge in 2005. Philosopher mary midgley thinker, writer and nemesis of the selfish gene, herald scotland, 31 march 2015. Darwin and the selfish gene kindle edition by midgley, mary. Mary midgley describes herself as a freelance philosopher, specialising in moral philosophy. Mary midgley argues in her powerful new book that far from being the opposite of science, myth is a central part of it. According to midgley, this is a serious misinterpretation of darwin, who viewed all organisms as. In april 2009 midgley reiterated her critical interpretation of the selfish gene as part of a series of articles on hobbes in the guardian. Subsequently she has written over 15 other books, including animals and why they matter 1983. The philosopher mary midgley has in recent years criticised richard dawkins, not because of his attack on religion, though she feels his attack has weaknesses, but because of his use of the word selfishness, and his psychological account of the human condition, and therefore human morality, in terms of being selfish. Darwin and the selfish gene paperback 2010 author mary midgley on. Dawkins selfish gene is now approaching its 35th anniversary.
Over the years, as each of my seven subsequent books has appeared, publishers have sent me on tour to promote it. In brilliant prose, she claims that myths are neither lies nor mere stories but a network of powerful symbols that suggest particular ways of interpreting the world. Mary midgley feared and admired in equal measure, mary midgley has carefully yet profoundly challenged many of the scientific and moral orthodoxies of the twentieth century. Dec 05, 2014 renowned philosopher mary midgley explores the nature of our moral constitution to challenge the view that reduces human motivation to selfinterest. Midgley argues cogently and convincingly that simple, onesided accounts of human motives, such as the selfish gene tendency in recent neodarwinian thought, may be illuminating. Oct 19, 2018 mary midgley, who has died aged 99, was a moral philosopher who made enormous contributions to human thinking on questions such as the self, our animal heritage and our place in the universe.
Oct 19, 2018 mary midgley, philosopher, 1919 to 2018. Mary midgleys reconstruction of evolution and its meanings. Midgley dismisses dawkins views as scientism and attacked him vociferously after the publication of his book the selfish gene, in spite of general acclaim. Mary midgley project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. Mary midgley renowned philosopher mary midgley explores the nature of our moral constitution to challenge the view that reduces human motivation to selfinterest.
1329 878 700 1232 1246 1198 969 319 514 606 1459 1305 552 488 958 367 132 829 638 615 305 754 427 1026 1433 353 1195 355 1169 368 1135 204